Is a Kitchen Island Worth It? Design Tips for Making It Work

Stirling
May 27
3 min read

If you're planning a kitchen remodel, chances are the idea of adding a kitchen island has crossed your mind. From added storage to a casual dining spot, islands have become one of the most popular features in modern kitchen design—but is one right for your space?

At Stirling Painting & Renovations, we’ve helped dozens of homeowners design smart, functional kitchens with (and without) islands. Here’s how to decide if a kitchen island is worth it—and how to make sure it works beautifully if you choose to include one.

🏝️ Why Kitchen Islands Are So Popular

A well-designed island can transform your kitchen by adding:

Extra counter space for food prep
Casual seating for meals, homework, or conversation
Storage solutions like cabinets, drawers, or built-in appliances
A natural gathering area that blends form and function

Islands also offer visual structure, especially in open-concept homes where they help define the kitchen zone.

🧱 Is Your Kitchen Big Enough for an Island?

Not all kitchens can comfortably accommodate an island—space is key. A good rule of thumb:

You’ll need at least 36–42 inches of clearance on all sides of the island for safe movement.
Ideal kitchen width for an island is at least 12 feet.

If your kitchen is on the smaller side, we can explore alternatives like a peninsula, mobile island, or extending countertop space in other creative ways.

📏 Kitchen Island Sizing Guidelines

Here’s a general guide we use when helping homeowners plan their islands:

Minimum size: 24” deep × 36” long (just for prep or minimal use)
Ideal size for seating: 24” of width per stool
Height: Standard islands are 36” high; bar-style islands are 42”

The right size depends on your kitchen's layout, how you plan to use the island, and whether it will include a sink, cooktop, or seating area.

🔌 Island Features to Consider

What do you want your island to do? It can be much more than a flat surface:

Storage: Add cabinets, drawers, or pull-out shelves
Appliances: Include a sink, dishwasher, microwave, or wine fridge
Electrical: Add outlets for mixers, phones, or laptops
Lighting: Pendant lights or under-counter LEDs add both function and ambiance

Our team at Stirling helps design islands that match your workflow, style, and storage needs—not just a “standard box.”

🎨 Style and Aesthetic Tips

Your island can complement or contrast your cabinetry for a custom, built-in look.

Popular Design Ideas:

Waterfall countertops for a sleek, modern edge
Furniture-style islands with legs or decorative trim
Two-tone cabinetry to add visual interest
Shiplap or beadboard finishes for a farmhouse or coastal look

Because we specialize in both carpentry and custom painting, we can help make your island a true design centerpiece.